CJI Dipak Misra reads out the verdcit of Section 377

10 September, 2018, 10:34 | Author: Angel Logan
  • India's top court to rule on decriminalizing gay sex

In January this year, Supreme Court said a larger group of judges would re-consider the previous judgment (which reinforced criminalisation of homosexuality) and examine Section 377's constitutional validity. Respect for each other's rights and others are supreme humanity. "Nation after nation has been extending full rights to gay people under the law, and now India, as the world's second-most populous country, stands, at least legally, among the more progressive", the paper wrote.

Members of the LGBT community hugged each other and cried outside the Supreme Court in New Delhi as news of the verdict spread.

Section 377 had prohibited "carnal intercourse against the order of nature with any man, woman or animal" - which was widely interpreted as referring to homosexual sex. "The veil of social morality can not be used to violate fundamental rights of even a single individual, for the foundation of constitutional morality rests upon the recognition of diversity that pervades the society", CJI Misra ruled.

Justice Chandrachud said, "Why do politicians sometimes hand over power to judges and we see that happening in the Supreme Court everyday".

BBC revealed that the ruling was delivered by a five-judge bench headed by India's outgoing chief justice Dipak Misra.

The battle to repeal Section 377 began in 2001, when a group called the Naz Foundation challenged it in court.

"So pleased to learn that the Supreme Court has ruled against criminalising sexual acts in private".

Until today, nine still had the original British laws in place more or less unchanged, including India.

Justice Indu Malhotra, a member of the bench in her separate judgment, said that history owed an apology to the members of this community and their families, for the delay in providing redressal for the ignominy and ostracism that they have suffered through the centuries.

He said the denial of right to sexual orientation was akin to denial of right to privacy and the society can not dictate sexual relationship between consenting adults as it was a private affair.

After the apex court had set aside the Delhi High Court's 2009 judgement decriminalising sex between consenting adults of the same sex by holding Section 377 of IPC as "illegal", review petitions were filed.

The court found that the ban - and punishment of as much as 10 years in prison - had effectively "closeted" the LGBT community, which it said has the same rights as others in Indian society. "There are other judgments which do not regard this right "to be that I am" as something that is immutable", he said.

The bench, which also comprised Justices R F Nariman, A M Khanwilkar and D Y Chandrachud, struck down part of section 377 of the IPC as being violative of the right to equality and the right to live with dignity.

Former Union Health Minister Harsh Vardhan had said in 2014, "Everybody has human rights, and it is the government's job to protect them". However, the bench made it clear that sex with animals, which also forms a part of Section 377, will remain a criminal offence.

Recommended:

  • Tropical storm Florence could cause damage along East Coast

    Tropical storm Florence could cause damage along East Coast

    The storm reached major hurricane status Wednesday, peaking with maximum sustained winds of 130 miles per hour (210 kph). Cooper signed a transportation waiver that would allow farmers to harvest and transport their crops more quickly.
    Apple refuses a giant iPhone Plus 2018

    Apple refuses a giant iPhone Plus 2018

    Here's a not particularly well-kept secret for you: us tech sites keep a check on which iPhone-related keywords are trending. As for the design of the new iPhones, all of them will feature a similar design to the previous generation of iPhones.
    Ronaldo, Modric, Salah nominated but Messi snubbed — FIFA Awards

    Ronaldo, Modric, Salah nominated but Messi snubbed — FIFA Awards

    He was runner-up in the prize in 2007 and 2008 before winning the title for the first of five years in 2009. Cristiano Ronaldo was nursing a black eye on Wednesday as he trained at Juventus HQ in Turin.
  • Nishikori bests Cilic in US Open rematch, moves to semis

    Nishikori bests Cilic in US Open rematch, moves to semis

    She needed just 26 minutes to win the first set and finished the match in just under an hour. Millman broke Djokovic's serve just once, whereas Djokovic broke Millman's serve four times.
    Djokovic tops Nishikori for 8th US Open final

    Djokovic tops Nishikori for 8th US Open final

    Del Potro had a 7-6 (3), 6-2 lead. "I said to my box immediately that I felt something on the knee", Nadal said. I got depressed for couple of months also, "Del Potro said". "I don't like to see him suffering like today".
    Welcome back (to reality), Earl Thomas

    Welcome back (to reality), Earl Thomas

    Thomas' reaction to the lack of a resolution was clear in his post: "The disrespect has been noted and will not be forgotten". A source confirmed to ESPN's Dan Graziano that there's no new deal in place between Seattle and Thomas.
  • Mueller to accept written answers from Trump in Russian Federation  inquiry, report says

    Mueller to accept written answers from Trump in Russian Federation inquiry, report says

    In March, Mueller raised the prospect of subpoenaing Trump if he refused to be questioned voluntarily. The president's team has also reportedly been wary of sending Trump into an interview with Mueller.
    Pompeo accuses Russian Federation  of justifying Idlib offensive

    Pompeo accuses Russian Federation of justifying Idlib offensive

    Thousands protested in various towns in Idlib and Hama, denouncing threats of an attack and hailing the area's readiness to fight. The three leaders have previously held summits in the Russian resort city of Sochi and the Turkish capital Ankara.
    Woodward book prompts West Wing witch hunt, sources say

    Woodward book prompts West Wing witch hunt, sources say

    But insiders speculated the fallout could be worse than that from "Fire and Fury", given Woodward's storied reputation. Sessions has been a target of the president's wrath since recusing himself from the Russian Federation investigation.
  • Sergio Ramos dismisses latest bust-up with Mo Salah

    Sergio Ramos dismisses latest bust-up with Mo Salah

    That decision was reportedly opposed by numerous senior players in the Spain squad, including captain Sergio Ramos . The team has had plenty of success in the last ten years, winning the 2008 Euro, 2012 Euro and 2010 World Cup .
    Russia Launches Airstrikes in Syria's Rebel-Held Idlib

    Russia Launches Airstrikes in Syria's Rebel-Held Idlib

    Erdogan has warned against such a catastrophic outcome, and has much at stake in efforts to prevent it at the Tehran summit. The Assad government was not directly represented at the summit, nor was the United States or other Western powers.
    Explosive quotes from Bob Woodward's book about Trump

    Explosive quotes from Bob Woodward's book about Trump

    He's gone off the rails. "I spoke to you 20 years [ago] and I spoke to you a year and a half or two years ago". Let's kill the fucking lot of them", Trump reportedly told him. "We're going to be much more measured".


Popular

Tropical Storm Helene forms in eastern Atlantic
He said: "We are entering the peak of hurricane season and we know well the unpredictability and power of these storms". Winds peaked at 130 miles per hour Wednesday before weakening to 60 miles per hour on Friday.

Alibaba’s Jack Ma, China’s richest man, to retire at 54
The New York Times is blocked in China by Communist Party censors and there was no official statement from Alibaba on Saturday. Ma said the move will be " the beginning of an era " and revealed that he may now focus on education, which he " loves ".

USA charges North Korean spy over NHS cyber attack
The attacks are alleged to have been carried out from North Korea, China and other countries. "We will get it done together!" The charges were brought against Park as the Trump administration seeks to improve relations with North Korea.

Trump suggests anonymous author was a 'low-level' staffer
She called the story's publication "another example of the liberal media's concerted effort to discredit the President". At the same time , I can't say whether we would have done it or not, so I don't want to sound churlish.

Trump Blames Sessions For Arrests Of GOP Reps
The courts shall decide their guilt or innocence. "I think Sessions is a very smart man and a man of integrity". Republicans control both the House and Senate and the elections will decide whether they keep their majorities.

Birthday girl Carla Suarez Navarro upsets Maria Sharapova
Since returning from her drugs ban previous year , Sharapova has made just one quarter-final in five grand slams . And now she could be set to match up against another American: Serena Williams in the semifinal.

Arizona Gov. Taps Jon Kyl as McCain Senate Replacement
The unusual timing of Kyl's appointment could work out for another Arizona Republican who wants to become a USA senator - Rep. Arizona voters will get to decide who should fill McCain's former seat in the 2020 election and then again in 2022.

Rafael Nadal needs 5 sets, almost 5 hours to outlast Dominic Thiem
Rafael Nadal watched as his opponent hit an overhead beyond the baseline on match point and then dropped his racket to his side. There are no chill Rafael Nadal matches, like oh cool, I'll watch some tennis and my blood pressure will stay level.

Chrome 69 Released With Enhanced Security, Customization, and Design
With this release, Google is using the Material Design framework across the desktop, iOS , and Android versions of Chrome . Google has adopted its Material Design 2 philosophy to give the browser an all-new design, which is a welcome move.

Jim Furyk Announces Three Of His Ryder Cup Wildcards
The idea is to find the hottest player to fill out the team, and no one has been close to DeChambeau over the last two weeks. Though Woods has not won since 2013, he finished runner up at the Valspar Championship and PGA Championship this season.